Forward any questions
or submissions to the
Webmaster

.A ministry of
The Baptist Page
  © 1997-2001
All rights reserved


 

Book Review
March 14, 2001

Spurgeon & Hyper-Calvinism by Iain H. Murray

With over 80 volume of his writings and sermons in print, one may ask how this little book could add anymore to the life of Charles Spurgeon. The answer is found within the pages of Spurgeon & Hyper-Calvinism. While his published works are immense Spurgeon's life and ministry embodied a simple message. Spurgeon once said of Bunyan, "Prick him anywhere and his blood is bibline." Murray notes the same could have been said about Spurgeon.

The Chapter, A Life of Testimony of the Word of God, presents this core feature of Spurgeon's life and message. He was first and foremost commited to God's Word. That meant he found himself at times more aligned with Bible-believing non-Baptists than with his peers in the London Baptist Union. Spurgeon also equated the move away from the doctrines of grace with a move away from God's Word itself.

In his chapter, The Combatants and the Cause of the Controversy, Murray details the first attacks that came against Spurgeon. He notes that those first shots fired were accusations that Spurgeon was not trully Calvinist. Words such as 'mongrel' and 'Fullerite' were hurled with impunity at the new kid on the block among London Baptists. The real problem was this; Spurgeon was a Biblical preacher. He did not preach from systematic theologies but instead from the Word itself. As a result he had no problem with preaching the Sovereignty of God and the responsbility of man in the same breath.

Lessons from the Conflict, gives us some important guidelines to dealing with each other in the midst of theological differences. The tension between love for the brethren and love for the truth will always be with us. In fact what Spurgeon feared most was that Baptists were losing that tension. Much of the Down-grade Controversy had to do with Spurgeon's belief that Baptists were beginning to love getting along with each more than getting along with God.

Read this book with an open heart and mind. Also be sure to read Murray's earlier work, The Forgotten Spurgeon. Together these books give us an insightful picture of the greatest Baptist of all.

Spurgeon & Hyper-Calvinism: The Battle for Gospel Preaching by Iain H. Murray (The Banner of Truth Trust, 1995), paper, 164 pages.

.

In his maturer years he (Spurgeon) indeed came to use all 'labels' more sparingly, not because his mind was changed on the errors in question, but rather because the best way to help others is simply to teach the Scriptures. (p. xv)

It is estimated that each week his 'congregation' amounted to about a million people. By 1899 it is on record that 'over an hundred millions' of his sermons had been issued in twenty-three languages. (p. 11)

He was a definite Baptist but ... allegiance to evangelicalism took precedence over the things which alligned him with Baptists ... Spurgeon regarded it as a tragedy that Baptists put their denominational unity before a higher claim. (p.15)

The later years of Spurgeon's life were the most difficult for him. Instead of regarding him as a leader in evangelical belief, many now though of him as an obstinate spokesman for a bygone era, 'the last of the Puritans.' Within his lifetime multitudes of professing Christians had passed from Calvinism to Arminanism ... to doubting the full inspiration of the Bible. (p. 25)

Jesus wants nothing from you, nothing whatsoever, nothing done, nothing felt; He gives both work and feeling. Ragged, penniless, just as you are, lost, forsaken, desolate, with no good feelings, and no good hopes, still Jesus comes to you, and in these words of pity He addresses you, "Him that cometh unto Me I will in wise cast out." (p. 79)

The old-fashioned high Calvinist are passing away ... their places are not occupied by better men. (The man today)... believes in nothing but its own cleverness. We would sooner have the narrowness of those who have gone than the emptiness of those who ridicule them. (p. 105)

Return to Reading Page