Introduction and Chapter One:
Coming to A New Land 

“,,, and you just don’t know what all I had to go through to even be here today.”

As though being shaken awake from a fitful dream, the pastor caught those last few words from Mrs. Johnson. She had embarked on one of her weekly soliloquies of woe and now waited for affirmation from her spiritual leader. “Yes, sister, “ he replied,” there is always sacrifice in serving our Lord.” However, before he could point out that what she was experiencing might not qualify as sacrifice she interrupted, “Yea, and all who live godly in Christ Jesus shall suffer persecution.” Satisfied with her own affirmation of costly discipleship evidenced by driving her new Oldsmobile a whole three miles to church, Mrs. Johnson hurried out the door of the church building with a wave and a smile.

 Pastor Wilkins had a very different emotion. He was not at all pleased with his words or those of the satisfied saint now on her way to a date with Sunday pot roast and the Green Bay Packers. For some reason Brother Wilkins felt led earlier that morning to walk through the church cemetery as he gathered his thoughts for the day’s sermon. For almost one hundred and seventy five years the saints and not-so-saintly had been laid to rest on these grounds. There were the shiny new  marble tombstones of the recently departed. There were also the weathered, white and black tinged reminders of people whose names had long since been forgotten. Rich, poor, free and slave all had been buried on that same piece of real estate in a place called Simpson County, Mississippi.

As the pastor walked through that place his mind whirred with thought. His sermon that day was to be, “What mean these stones?” He was prepared to tell his congregation of how Israel was told to take stones from the bed of the parted Jordan River and build an altar. When the next generation asked, “What mean these stones?,” they were to recount how God had brought them into the Promised Land. God warned Moses years before that Israel would quickly forget their spiritual heritage and would often need reminders of the blessings of God and the faithfulness of their forefathers.

Now that the sermon had been preached, Brother Wilkins thought of the morning. Mrs. Johnson wasn’t the only fly in the ointment that day. First there had been the argument that arose between the preacher’s kids and mom over what clothes to wear that day. Then, only one faithful man showed up for prayer time before Sunday School. Added to that was his own nagging realization that maybe the pastor didn’t understand fully himself what it meant to sacrifice for Christ. So, instead of heading straight for the parsonage John Wilkins found himself once again walking through those silent reminders of the past. What would these stones of remembrance say if they could speak? What stories of faith and perseverance could they tell? What were these people like who came to settle in Simpson County Mississippi and found Baptist churches in the early 1800’s? How could this young pastor get his own people too see that the present is never disconnected from the past? How could he get them to understand, “What means these stones?”

What began as a whim turned into a  passion. Pastor Wilkins began to research the beginnings of Baptist work in Simpson County. He gathered mounds of paper which told sketchy stories of various pioneers of the area. Now he could begin to tell the story of this people. But where to start? Perhaps the story of Simpson Baptist Association could begin like any other history. . It could begin with names and dates - names like Josiah Simpson for whom the county was named. Simpson was a former Pennsylvanian and educated at Princeton. He later lived at Green Hill, near Natchez, and became a territorial judge of Mississippi. Then there would be names of people, names of churches, things they did, things they said. And so on and so forth. “No!, thought Wilkins, “there must be a better way to tell this story. Let’s see maybe we should go back to where it all began.

 

Chapter One: The Story Begins

John Guynes sat in the crowded pew of the Hebron Baptist Church of Lawrence County and listened intently. Samuel B. Mullen, the pastor of Sardis Baptist Church in Copiah county led in prayer and then called the delegates to order. A roll was called and a vote taken to form a new body to be named the Strong River Baptist Association. It was a new body but Guynes was not new to Baptist work. His church, like the others gathered, was a long standing member of the Pearl River Association, the second oldest Baptists association in the state of Mississippi. This was truly a great day for these 17 churches spread out over four counties. There were over 600 Baptists believers in theses little fellowships separated by miles of vast forest land but connected by a common desire to see the Kingdom of God built up in their state.[1]

As reports were given, John couldn’t help be find his mind wandering to other events in the Guynes family. News had come of a new addition to their family on the edge of Simpson and Copiah counties. A baby girl by the name of Matilda had been born. Little did he know that Matilda, like many women in her day, would die young. Matilda later married John A. Barlow of Harrisville and left this earth at the premature age of 24. Even in 1853 life was still hard for the people of Simpson, Copiah, Lawrence and Rankin counties. Money was scarce, travel was arduous and it was still very much a young land.

Those first delegates were still of  the era that could remember the stories of their fathers and how they traveled to a place called Mississippi. When Matilda Guynes married John A. Barlow she married into a family that could trace their roots back as far as Sir Walter Raleigh. More importantly John’s forefather, another John Barlow had been one of the first to make the journey to central and southern Mississippi from northern Georgia. So that is who will tell our story of how Baptists found themselves in a place called Simpson County Mississippi …

 … John and Lydia Barlow had made up their minds. It was time to move on to a new place. Wilkinson County Georgia with all of its charm did not hold the appeal of a new frontier called The Mississippi Territory. Land grants were being offered in the vast area still under the general control of the Governor of Georgia. Great tracts of virgin timberland awaited those who were either foresighted enough or foolhardy enough to make the journey. New Orleans, Baton Rogue and Natchez all had been settled for some time but the interior country of central and southern Mississippi was for the most part uninhabited.

 1811 interior Mississippi was uninhabited by the white man but not by Native Americans. Great Native American nations existed throughout the region between North Carolina and Mississippi. The French had left the once proud nation of the Natchez all but extinct but the Creek, Cherokee, and Choctaw still ruled vast stretches of this virgin land. Just two years later in 1813 the Creek Nation rose up against the inhabitants at Fort Mims in southern Alabama and massacred nearly all of the 550 people that had sought protection there. Though there were few other such attacks a general panic enveloped the citizens of the southern portion of the Mississippi Territory. Rumors abounded of scalped men and abducted women.

Because of the hostile territory between them and their promised land of Mississippi, John and Lydia had to apply for a passport from the Governor of Georgia before they could embark on their journey.[2] Finally the passport was signed by Governor Mitchell on February 9, 1810 and in 1811 John and Lydia Barlow, their children, several in-laws and seven inherited slaves headed off for a new land. They carried with them the dreams of every American pioneer, the faith of solid Baptists from the Charleston tradition, and the hopes of a new place on which to pin their family heritage. They also carried with them unresolved issues which the Baptists of Simpson and other counties in Mississippi would have to address sooner or later. The “Indian Problem” as some called it was not to go away quickly nor was it always dealt with in a Christlike manner. Strong River Association had to address how to handle the then vanquished remnants of those same Indian nations early in its history. While Negroes were members of those first churches, they were members as slaves not as freedmen. That too would have to be dealt with somehow. But back to our story.

Getting from Northern Georgia to Mississippi in 1811 was no easy matter. The United States of America was only 35 years old and road systems to the West and South were almost non-existent.  To lead a family on such a trip was considered difficult by all and insane by many. But neither Indians nor hardship could hold back these adventurous folk. John, Lydia and their little band loaded all that they owned and along with other travelers gathered in the Pee Dee River Area. Located in what is now Florence, South Carolina, the Pee Dee was to people headed from the East Coast what St. Louis was for those were headed further West. A few years earlier and the Pee Dee would have been no place to bring a family, even if it was for just a short stay. This was a place which for years had been a very remote area; isolated from the influence of church and state. Crime was rampant. Lack of schools were a problem also. It was written at the time, that the "lack of education led to idle, immoral lives- follow hunting, shooting, racing, drinking, gaming, and every aspect of wickedness, more rude in manners than the savages around us". Fortunately some Welch Baptists moved into area in 1738 and formed the Welch Neck Baptist Church which had mothered the Ebenezer Baptist Church by the time the Barlows came into town. Perhaps their family worshiped at Ebenezer before embarking on their great adventure.

From there it was a 200 mile trip by pack mule to the Houston River in Northeastern Tennessee. At that point the settlers made their way South on the Warrior’s Path and then the Wilderness Road ending at Kingsport, Tennessee. By now they had taken weeks to travel a distance which can be traveled in five hours by car today. Once at Kingsport it was time to build a flatboat and float the family and belongings down the Tennessee River near Knoxville. John’s brow was furrowed as he sat quietly, studying the river journey that lay ahead of them. This was the most dangerous time of their lives. Indian attacks were common against the flatboats. Lydia would steer the boat over the coming days while John and the other men in their group watched for and often fought off small bands of Creeks and Cherokees. But all danger aside, they loaded up everything they owned on the hastily built flatboat. Methodist Circuit Rider Timothy Flint recalled that it was "no uncommon spectacle to see a large family, old and young, servants, cattle, hogs [on flatboats] ... bringing to recollection the cargo of the ancient ark." These boats could range anywhere from 20 to 100 feet long and really did have a resemblance to the Ark of old. Though rough and sometimes crude, the flatboats were the trains of their day. Children, rough furniture, cows, pigs and chickens were all loaded aboard and again the Barlows and Baptists were on their way to Mississippi.

Following the Tennessee River they reached the Ohio River at Paducah, Kentucky and from the Ohio they finally entered the mighty Mississippi River. Moving at whatever pace Big Muddy chose to take them the Barlow clan floated past towns such as Memphis, Vicksburg, and then Natchez. Past the dangers of Indians they now faced the peril of robbers of the white variety. One such robber, feared by all on the way, was Joseph Thompson Hare. Hare had committed crimes everywhere from New York City to New Orleans. While hiding out near Natchez, Hare wrote, "Let not any one be induced to turn highwayman by reading this book and seeing the great sums of money I have robbed, for it is a desperate life, full of danger, and sooner or later ends at the gallows." Indeed his life did end at the gallows in 1818. God’s providence smiled on the Barlows and protected them from such men.  So John and Lydia along with a number of other settlers continued down the Mississippi River until they reached the Homochitto River of South Mississippi. By now the Barlows had traveled 1700 miles by wagon, mule, foot, and water. They had faced Indians, yellow fever, flooded rivers, hunger and isolation. It had taken eleven months of perseverance and faith. But at last, they were home.

There was still much to do after arriving in their new land. Some of those great forests had to be cut down to build homes. Wild game was abundant as were fish from the rivers. Unlike the Creeks, the Choctaw Indians of Mississippi were for the most part friendly. The Choctaws contributed greatly to the success of the migrating folk from the Eastern Seaboard. Their trails became the first roads used by white men. While most of the Choctaws had moved further north in Mississippi by 1824, Westville was still seen as a major crossroads for Indian trails. . The great chief Pushmataha was made Chief of the Choctaw Nation in 1812. Pushmataha was greatly admired by then General Andrew Jackson and was buried in the Congressional Cemetery in Washington with honors at his death. Thus the Choctaws posed no problem for these arrivals to the Mississippi Territory. But other dangers lurked around the bend and in the heart.

 Somehow John ended up settling in what is now Perry County where he soon became a constable. Life was good in the new land but as always man carries not only his dreams but his nightmares. For deep and bitter reasons John and Lydia were divorced in 1827. After surviving all the rigors of a pioneer journey they had fallen to that most deadly of enemies, the human heart. John died two years later of yellow fever and was buried near Natchez. Lydia and the children ended up in Simpson County. 

It would be easy to forget, for those raised on Roy Rodgers and John Wayne, that in the early 1800’s it was Mississippi that was called the great Southwest and not Arizona. Dodge City out in Kansas was still a dream when Westville in central Simpson County had already become somewhat notorious as a place for hard drinking and sometimes hard fighting. The people who found their way to Mississippi were for the most part hard-working farmers whose parents and grandparents had come to America from Scotland, Ireland and England. The majority were of Scotch-Irish descent and they brought with them the characteristics of Highlanders. "Every man did what was right in his own eyes, but in spite of a general recklessness, there was a rough code of honor and honesty which was rarely broken. The settlers lived a life of great toil and many privations …"[3]

As in most areas, water was as important if not more so than any other consideration in deciding where to settle. Among others, James Briggs, James McDuff, and James Powell planted their lives and fortunes at Vaughn’s Creek in Southeastern Simpson County. These three James’ all became influential leaders in the early years of the county. Briggs was later elected sheriff, McDuff built the first mill at Vaughn’s Creek and Powell was pastor of Strong River Baptist Church for a number of years.

Down in the Southwestern corner of Simpson County on the Lawrence County Line settled the Murrays, Walkers, Boggans, Weathersbys, Fortenberrys, Shivers, and Tolers. No three families played a greater role in the early growth of Baptist that than the Murrays, Walkers and Tolers. People to this day who live in Simpson County know exaclty where Boggan Ridge is. Though it has lost its charter, thousands of cars pass Weathersby every single day on US 49.

 In the South Central part of Simpson County was Good Water Creek. Many settled in the genereal area but none so remembered as Phillip Magee. About five miles from Westville another community formed near the Strong River. Among those first settlers were  David Bishop, John Phillips, L.G. Gibson, Alex McNair, and Nathan Bush. Strong River Church became the first Baptist Church organized inside the county of Simpson in 1827.  Bethlehem Church, formerly called Fork and founded over in Copiah County was nearby in the Union community. To the Northeast of Simpson County people settled in what became known as Pearl, named after the river upon whose banks they settled.  All the way across the county was Bouie Creek where Mt. Zion Church was moved from Covington County.

Sometimes, history is forged as much by seeming accidents as intentional plans. Early in the Spring of 1829 settlers in four ox-drawn wagons were traveling together toward the "Big Road" on their way to Natchez. When these hardy souls got to Limestone Creek it had overflowed the banks leaving no way of crossing. These four families made camp, planted crops and before long had decided to just put down stakes where Providence had led then. Before long there were Buckleys, Barlows, Bridges, Harris’s, Mahaffeys, Guynes, Neelys, Berrys, Keens, Tuckers and many others in what came to be called Harrisville. [4]

 Thus did Baptists arrive in Simpson, Lawrence, Copiah, and Rankin counties of Mississippi. Some came like the Barlows. Others traveled down the Natchez Trace. Still others came by way of Mobile.  There were mountain people, Scottish Highlanders, and the descendents of English aristocrats. They all came for the fresh water and abundant timber. They came with their hopes, their dreams, their faith and their churches. They also came with their fears, their failings and their sins. After all, that is why there is a church. Sheep need a fold and a shepherd and there were now sheep in Simpson County.


[1] Boyd,  J.L., Abstract History of Simpson County Baptist Association (formerly Strong River) 1927, pp. 1-6). Dr. Boyd was pastor of First Baptist Church Magee, Clerk of the Association for many years and the first curator of the Mississippi Baptist Historical Archives at Mississippi College.
Back to Text.

[2] Different accounts have the Barlows either taking the route described here or the overland route through Alabama. Since they did not leave for Mississippi until over a year after applying for a passport from the Governor of Georgia it is uncertain which route was taken. Back to Text.

[3] Davis, Reuben, Recollection of Mississippi and Mississippians, Boston: Houghton, Miffin & Co., pp. 3-4. Back to Text.

[4] Simpson County Sesquicentennial Historical Booklet, 1974, p. 16. Referred to hereafter as SCSHB Back to Text.

 

©2000
The Baptist Page

All writings contained herein are protected by US copyright laws and all rights are reserved.